On Wednesday, the New York Post broke news of the star's passing, writing in a report: "Trachtenberg was found by her mother at around 8 a.m. Wednesday at One Columbus Place, a 51-story luxury apartment complex in Manhattan’s Central Park South neighborhood."
Earlier this month, reports revealed that Buffy - in which Trachtenberg played the character Dawn Summers - is set to be revived in a continuation series with lead star Sarah Michelle Gellar expected to return in her iconic role.
On Wednesday, news broke that the star had tragically died at the age of 39 - with reports suggesting she had recently undergone surgery and that police were not treating the death as mysterious.
Michelle Trachtenberg left her fans concerned weeks before her shock death as she shared photographs of herself looking gaunt.
Weeks before her death, Trachtenberg had taken to social media to post photographs of herself posing in a blue jumper with an animal embroidered on the front.