Is Costco worth it? As chain hikes membership prices, we reveal who shouldn’t shop there & the one deal EVERYONE loves

Is Costco worth it? As chain hikes membership prices, we reveal who shouldn’t shop there & the one deal EVERYONE loves
Share:
Is Costco worth it? As chain hikes membership prices, we reveal who shouldn’t shop there & the one deal EVERYONE loves
Author: Emma Lake
Published: Feb, 13 2025 14:20

WITH over two million members and 29 locations in the UK, Costco is often regarded as THE destination for bulk-buying. But with membership prices set to go up in weeks, are their deals still saving you money? And is it still worth signing up?. The US wholesale warehouse chain has amassed a cult following since it first opened here in 1993. But now the price of its annual membership is set to rise by up to 42 per cent.

 [People entering and leaving a Costco Wholesale store.]
Image Credit: The Sun [People entering and leaving a Costco Wholesale store.]

From March 1, the fee to sign up to Costco will go from £28 to £35 for individual members. We’ve investigated the new membership terms as well as the price of top items to see if its fees and bargains are worthwhile, as well as who is getting their money's worth and who isn't. As well as the membership price hike, adding an extra cardholder onto that policy will now cost £20 up from £14 - a 42 per cent increase.

 [Price comparison of Cushelle toilet paper at Costco and Asda.]
Image Credit: The Sun [Price comparison of Cushelle toilet paper at Costco and Asda.]

Trade customers will pay £25 for membership from next month - up from £22 now. Individual membership fees have VAT added at the checkout too, meaning the total cost of annual Costco membership will be £42 - up from £33.60. Shoppers need to ensure that their bulk purchases genuinely save them money. Business customers will pay £30 including VAT - although businesses can claim back this tax on both membership and any purchases at the store.

 [Activia Gut Health yogurt price comparison: Costco (£6.48) vs Asda (£7.94).]
Image Credit: The Sun [Activia Gut Health yogurt price comparison: Costco (£6.48) vs Asda (£7.94).]

There is a hack to avoid the hike this year, however. If you renew your membership before March 1, you’ll pay the current price and membership can be renewed up to 90 days ahead of your card’s expiry. Experts are warning the new, pricier, cost of being a Costco member won’t be worth it for some. “Shoppers need to ensure that their bulk purchases genuinely save them money,” says Richard Price, grocery expert and owner of online supermarket, Britsuperstore.

 [Price comparison of Scott's Porridge Oats at Costco (£4.39) and Big Foods (£3.50).]
Image Credit: The Sun [Price comparison of Scott's Porridge Oats at Costco (£4.39) and Big Foods (£3.50).]

“To make the £35 individual annual membership worthwhile, a shopper should be saving at least £3 per month (or around 70p per week) compared to supermarket prices. “Those who regularly buy household essentials, cleaning supplies, and non-perishable foods in bulk will likely see these savings quickly add up. "However, infrequent shoppers may find that the membership fee outweighs the benefits.". Budgeting experts used to recommend smaller households share the cost of a Costco membership with a friend to lower the price while still benefiting from access to bulk savings.

But alongside the price rise, Costco has announced new rules stating shoppers can only add an extra ‘gold star cardholder’ if they are a partner or spouse living in the same household. So for each household to break even on the extra £7 added to the membership, you’d need to save at least £7 more per year compared to regular supermarket shopping. “If bulk toilet paper at Costco offers a £3 saving per pack, purchasing three packs a year would justify the extra cost,” Richard adds.

Here, we compared the price of four popular items often found in shoppers' baskets to take a snapshot look at who comes out on top price wise. Costco was selling a 32 pack of Cushelle loo roll for £26.89, or 85p per roll - and there’s a minimum two-pack purchase, so you’d face an outlay of £53.78 for 64 loo rolls. But Asda is selling Cushelle loo roll for £4.68 for six rolls, or 78p per roll - and its rolls contain an average 252 sheets per roll, compared to the Costco pack’s 236 sheets.

And that's without factoring in the VAT and membership fee meaning Asda works out cheaper. If you're not fussy about brands, then it's worth looking at own-brand offerings. Online, Costco shoppers can buy a pack of a whopping 1,440 Kirkland loo rolls at just 55p per roll - but the average British home would struggle to find a place to hide over 1,000 toilet rolls!. What about other items? We looked at popular basket fillers.

We found Costco selling 16 Activia 0% fat mixed fruit yogurts for £3.99 thanks to a special offer running at its warehouses. However, on the same day, Asda was selling an eight-pack of the same yogurts for £3.97. This works out at 25p per yogurt at Costco versus 50p at Asda - but how much of a bargain that is, of course depends on whether you need and could consume 16 perishable yogurts before the use by date.

Costco was selling a 3kg box of Scott’s porridge oats for £4.39 but the same pack is available from Big Foods for just £3.50. If you’re not bothered about the brand name, supermarkets are much cheaper. Tesco’s porridge is £2.70 for 3kg. With prices changing daily and sometimes hourly thanks to dynamic pricing, finding the best deal can be anything but straightforward. It doesn't help that the items are slightly different in size too, so it's hard to compare like-for-like baskets.

And you need to make sure that you will use the items before they perish or that you have enough room to store them. HAYLEY Merrick started bulk-buying toiletries when she realised how much she could save by stocking up in big quantities. The 38-year-old from Staffordshire shared her top tips. THINK OUTSIDE THE BOX. She estimates to have saved hundreds - if not thousands of pounds - by bulk buying staple beauty products.

Share:

More for You

Top Followed