Safari, Apple's browser. While a UK regulator continues to say iPhone browser rules are anticompetitive, Apple's detailed response says these findings are wrong and unlawful, plus proposed remedies will create the problems they are supposed to solve. In November 2024, the UK's Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) released a preliminary report asserting that Apple's rules about web browsers on iPhone were limiting app developers' ability to innovate. Alongside Apple's filing, the CMA has now also published its own summary of Apple's position, following a meeting with the company in December 2024.
Where the CMA wants to impose remedies, similar to the EU's Digital Markets Act, on what it sees as anticompetitive issues, Apple says that there are no such issues. Apple also repeatedly questions the legality of the CMA's intention to impose remedies — and says these remedies will themselves cause harm to developers and consumers.
"The CMA cannot simply speculate that market features 'may' have such an effect, nor is it sufficient for the CMA to hypothesize that certain conduct could theoretically be optimized to allow for more competition," says Apple in its filing. "The CMA... has given undue weight to unsupported and outdated complaints, and little to no weight to the interests of consumers in having a user-friendly, stable and secure platform.".
"To conclude that there is an [Adverse Effect on Competition] AEC, the CMA must demonstrate the conduct in question results in the purported harm to consumers," it continues. "In fact, the CMA's proposed remedies threaten to degrade the robust iOS security and privacy protections and performance enhancements that Apple has created.".
Apple claims that there is already sufficient competition in mobile browsers on iOS. It says that both developers and users are satisfied with the current situation. The CMA has now published its summary of Apple's position, plus Apple's filings, and also similar ones from Google, which also question the legality of the regulator's findings. The regulator has not as yet published a final report.
It is due to do so, however. According to its own administrative timetable, the CMA should publish a final report in February or March 2025. The timetable then lists what it calls a statutory deadline of March 16, 2025. It's not clear yet what will happen immediately after this, because in certain investigations, the CMA can extend its consultation period.
Apple's arguments that everything should be left as it appears reasonable. Its longstanding claim that harm to security and privacy will come from remedies such as allowing third-party app stores as the EU, are true. Nonetheless, the UK could ultimately see third-party stores being required if the CMA chooses not to recognize the arguments against it.
William Gallagher has 30 years of experience between the BBC and AppleInsider discussing Apple technology. Outside of AppleInsider, he's best known for writing Doctor Who radio dramas for BBC/Big Finish, and is the De... Apple didn't simply change the expected iPhone SE 4 name to iPhone 16e — they're distinct product lines and all the data points to a strategy shift.
Apple retailers are competing for your business by knocking triple digits off the M4 Pro Mac mini, while the standard M4 model has dropped to $549. "Severance" has officially become the most-watched Apple TV+ series, beating out former champion "Ted Lasso" — but you're probably not surprised.
Apple's update to the iPhone SE adds a new design and Apple Intelligence, as well as a new name: iPhone 16e. Here's how it compares to yesterday's budget option — the iPhone 16. Google has announced that it's bringing a new feature to iPhone that enables users to quickly search while browsing the web or watching videos.
Apple has regularly stated what languages its Apple Intelligence will support over the course of 2025, but it has now confirmed which ones are coming in April. The iPhone 16e announcement video sticks to Apple's signature style, making a mid-cycle product feel just as important as a major launch.
The new iPhone 16e is surely the right combination of prices and features to be a hit, but the iPhone SE range that it has replaced will always be special. The Enhanced Visual Search in the iOS Photos app sends encrypted, anonymized data from photos to Apple. Here's what that means and how to turn it off.
