There's no plot, but this British drama pulsates with warmth and humanity: BRIAN VINER reviews Hard Truths

There's no plot, but this British drama pulsates with warmth and humanity: BRIAN VINER reviews Hard Truths

Share:
There's no plot, but this British drama pulsates with warmth and humanity: BRIAN VINER reviews Hard Truths
Published: Jan, 30 2025 22:25

Hard Truths (12, 97mins). Verdict: Leigh back on form. Rating:. Mike Leigh's mighty reputation as a filmmaker was built by gritty contemporary realism, and after a pair of pictures of contrasting merit set in the 19th century – 2014's captivatingly brilliant Mr Turner and the lumpen, hugely disappointing Peterloo (2018) – he returns to more familiar pastures with Hard Truths. Marianne Jean-Baptiste, working with Leigh for the first time since Secrets & Lies bagged her an Oscar nomination almost 30 years ago, is unlucky not to have another one for her intense and extraordinary performance as Pansy, a deeply unhappy, acid-tongued woman in the grip of what appears to be severe depression.

 [Leigh's mighty reputation as a filmmaker was built by gritty contemporary realism, and after a pair of pictures of contrasting merit set in the 19th century  he returns to more familiar pastures with Hard Truths]
Image Credit: Mail Online [Leigh's mighty reputation as a filmmaker was built by gritty contemporary realism, and after a pair of pictures of contrasting merit set in the 19th century  he returns to more familiar pastures with Hard Truths]

That quick synopsis might not propel you to your cinema seat with a spring in your step and a bag of Revels, I grant you. You might even prefer to do something that sounds more fun, like staying at home to clean the oven. But as ever with Leigh's best work – and this certainly qualifies – Hard Truths pulsates with humanity. There is warmth and humour rubbing shoulders with the wretchedness. Mike Leigh's Hard Truths stars Marianne Jean-Baptiste as Pansy, a deeply unhappy, acid-tongued woman in the grip of what appears to be severe depression.

 [It is a gripping, episodic study of an extended black British family, which sometimes switches its focus to Pansy's hairdresser sister Chantelle (left), as sunny as Pansy is sorrowful and beautifully played by Michele Austin]
Image Credit: Mail Online [It is a gripping, episodic study of an extended black British family, which sometimes switches its focus to Pansy's hairdresser sister Chantelle (left), as sunny as Pansy is sorrowful and beautifully played by Michele Austin]

Leigh's mighty reputation as a filmmaker was built by gritty contemporary realism, and after a pair of pictures of contrasting merit set in the 19th century  he returns to more familiar pastures with Hard Truths. Moreover, it is enlightening. We have an acquaintance very much like Pansy, and always regarded her as thoroughly unpleasant, one of life's irredeemable misanthropes. It hadn't occurred to me until watching this absorbing film that she is more than likely horribly depressed.

 [JK Simmons as Milton Berle from Saturday Night]
Image Credit: Mail Online [JK Simmons as Milton Berle from Saturday Night]

Pansy lives in a respectable suburban semi, somewhere in London, with her husband Curtley (David Webber), a plumber, and their aimless, overweight only son, 22-year-old Moses (Tuwaine Barrett). She is permanently furious with them and with the world at large. They in turn are incommunicative and taciturn. Whether their sullen introversion is a cause or a consequence of her misery, manifest also in anxiety and phobias, is never clear. Perhaps a little of both.

 [The stars of Saturday Night from left to right: Kim Matula, as Jane Curtain, Emily Fairn, as Laraine Newman, Gabriel La Belle, as Lorne Michaels, Rachel Sennott, as Rosie Shuster, and Matt Wood, as John Belushi]
Image Credit: Mail Online [The stars of Saturday Night from left to right: Kim Matula, as Jane Curtain, Emily Fairn, as Laraine Newman, Gabriel La Belle, as Lorne Michaels, Rachel Sennott, as Rosie Shuster, and Matt Wood, as John Belushi]

The film, crafted in Leigh's favoured way of intensive workshopping, with the actors encouraged to build the characters themselves, lacks anything that resembles an actual plot. Rather, it is a gripping, episodic study of an extended black British family, which sometimes switches its focus to Pansy's hairdresser sister Chantelle, as sunny as Pansy is sorrowful and beautifully played by Michele Austin (who was also in Secrets & Lies), and her two bright, highly engaging grown-up daughters, Kayla (Ani Nelson) and Aleisha (Sophia Brown).

 [Jack Lemmon and Shirley MacLaine in the 1960 classic The Apartment which is s getting a welcome re-release to mark the centenary of Lemmon's birth next week]
Image Credit: Mail Online [Jack Lemmon and Shirley MacLaine in the 1960 classic The Apartment which is s getting a welcome re-release to mark the centenary of Lemmon's birth next week]

It is a gripping, episodic study of an extended black British family, which sometimes switches its focus to Pansy's hairdresser sister Chantelle (left), as sunny as Pansy is sorrowful and beautifully played by Michele Austin. Occasionally, we get clues to Pansy's past. On Mother's Day, very grudgingly, she goes with Chantelle to visit their mother's grave, where old resentments spill out and their conversation sheds further light on her gloomy marriage. But the film is at its best (and oddly, funniest) when the savagely witty Pansy is out and about venting her splenetic rage: visiting the doctor, the dentist, in a check-out queue at the supermarket, in a car park.

 [Jack Quaid and Sophie Thatcher in Companion . It starts like a romantic comedy but it quickly mutates into a combination of thriller, horror and sci-fi, skilfully handled by writer-director Drew Hancock]
Image Credit: Mail Online [Jack Quaid and Sophie Thatcher in Companion . It starts like a romantic comedy but it quickly mutates into a combination of thriller, horror and sci-fi, skilfully handled by writer-director Drew Hancock]

I've seen Hard Truths twice now, and the first time I wondered whether Jean-Baptiste maybe overdoes it a little. But on second viewing, and with that acquaintance of ours in mind, I can appreciate what a superb performance it is, at the heart of a truly excellent film. Leigh will turn 82 next month. Happily, it is not too old for a blistering return to form. Saturday Night (15, 109mins). Verdict: Feverish drama.

Chevy Chase turns 82 this year, too. Of the main originals who in October 1975 took part in the opening broadcast of NBC's comedy show Saturday Night, later re-titled Saturday Night Live, he is one of the few still alive. So it must have been a blow when Chase reportedly told Jason Reitman, whose movie Saturday Night fictionalises the frantic lead-up to that inaugural show, that he should be 'embarrassed' by it.

JK Simmons as Milton Berle from Saturday Night. The stars of Saturday Night from left to right: Kim Matula, as Jane Curtain, Emily Fairn, as Laraine Newman, Gabriel La Belle, as Lorne Michaels, Rachel Sennott, as Rosie Shuster, and Matt Wood, as John Belushi. Well, I enjoyed it. Unfolding more or less in real time, the film chronicles the hours before transmission, with chaos all around, lights crashing down, a neurotic Billy Crystal (Nicholas Podany) fretting about his material, a fight between Chase (Cory Michael Smith) and co-star John Belushi (Matt Wood), and producer Lorne Michaels (Gabriel LaBelle) wondering if he'll have a career left by Sunday morning.

Share:

More for You

Top Followed